In Tracey Mollet's "With a smile and a song..." she aims to link the story of Snow White to the climate of the United States during the 1930s. Although there were a few shortcomings in her argument, overall I thought her piece was quite effective and her central idea (of linking history to literature) was novel.
To begin, Mollet backed her argument up the most of probably anyone we've read in class thus far. The first couple of pages are devoted entirely to presenting all the relevant background information regarding the cultural importance of Disney films. She is also successful in offering counter arguments by presenting information about Jack Zipes, a staunch Disney critic. By presenting this information, Mollet also utilizes the "funnel down" approach we discussed in class, first mentioning Disney films in general, then their cultural importance, and finally the significance of Snow White on 1930s America.
As a history buff, I found this development particularly interesting, as she described how Snow White ultimately was supposed to give America hope of recovery after a number of tough years financially. Nevertheless, it did seem like Mollet was over speculating in some instances, and while I could technically see her point, it just seemed like a stretch. For example, describing the Witch as the epitome of the 1920s mindset that needed to be dismissed in the 30s wasn't all too convincing. Additionally, there were a few instances where the flow between history and movie just didn't work, although that isn't entirely unexpected. When linking two very distinct things, it can be difficult to find the perfect balance, which Mollet tried hard to do.
Overall, the piece was well done and the arguments were fresh. Although many will consider it a pro Disney piece, more than anything it was explanatory, which is something I admire. She presented her views in a calculated way and let her ideas talk rather than her ego, which is easier said than done. I'm looking at you Zipes.
No comments:
Post a Comment